A DUTTON PARK COTTAGE
I learnt a lot about Dutton Park and Boggo Road Gaol whilst researching this timber cottage. In some ways, it was a bit trickier to find out information about the early residents of this home, as they were largely working class. When researching large fancy houses of wealthy families, I glean a lot of information from the social pages and notices of births, deaths and marriages in the newspapers of the time. Working class families were not as well documented however and often could not afford to advertise life events in the papers. I was still able to uncover many details of the residents though and the history of this cottage is just as fascinating as that of any grand home!
Vulture Street was originally the southern boundary of Brisbane Town, but gradually the settlement expanded outwards. Classified variously as part of South Brisbane, Woolloongabba and Boggo Road, the suburb of Dutton Park was eventually established and named after the Dutton Park reserve to the north of the South Brisbane Cemetery. The park had been gazetted in 1884 and was in turn named after the Secretary of Public Lands, Charles Boydell Dutton.
In February 1861, sixteen portions of land at South Brisbane, varying in size between approximately nine and twenty one acres, were advertised for sale. Edward Deighton Esquire, a clerk in the Colonial Architect’s Office, took advantage of these early land sales in March, purchasing eight of these allotments, covering almost 79 acres. Deighton therefore owned the majority of the land within the triangle formed by Old Ipswich Road (now Gladstone Road), Boggo Road (now Annerley Road) and Gloucester Street.
At the time he purchased the land, Deighton was leasing a house on Stanley Street at South Brisbane from his brother-in-law, and future mayor of Brisbane, Thomas Blacket Stephens. However, by October 1861, he and his family were living at a residence, “Wahcumba” on his new land, along the Old Ipswich Road (now Gladstone Road). Wahcumba was a large, eight-roomed house, on a large amount of land. When advertised for lease in July 1867, it is still situated on 42 acres. Today’s Deighton Road and Wahcumba Street at Dutton Park get their names from the family and the residence respectively.
Sometime around June 1876, Deighton subdivides Portions 215 and 216 into the “Deighton Estate”. He gives family names to the new streets in his estate, including Deighton Street (now Denbigh St), Nelson Street (his second wife’s maiden name) and Tillot Street (his mother’s maiden name). Sales of the suburban - sized allotments begin in July 1877 and continue until at least 1885. However, Edward never lives on the estate, remaining at Wahcumba until his death in July 1894.
On 20 August, 1883, labourer Robert Finney purchases Subdivision 67 in the Deighton Estate, on the northern side of Tillot Street. It is a long, narrow block, with a frontage of 61 feet (18.6m) and an area of 21 and 1/10 perches (549m2), which remain the dimensions of the current lot. He obviously wasn’t put off by the proximity of the new gaol, which had opened only the month before. Finney is living on Tillot Street by 1885, so presumedly the current house was built sometime between when he bought the vacant land in 1883 and this date.
In December 1891, a new railway extension from Melbourne Street (now South Brisbane station) to Boggo Road opened. There were stations at Gloucester Street (no longer there) and Park Road, and the line crossed Boggo Road on the same alignment it does today, quite close to Tillot Street. One wonders if Finney was happy with the convenience of living close by it, or disgruntled at the intrusion! Robert transfers the property to his son, John, in August 1899, however he only holds onto the house for a few months, selling it to John Gaffney in October. Robert Finney continues to live there until 1900, however he and his wife, Alice, remain in the South Brisbane area until his death on 7 February 1911.
The new owner of the property, John Gaffney, appears to have been an interesting character. He was an Irish immigrant who became a police officer, was an alderman and then Mayor of South Brisbane, had interests in multiple race horses, was president of the Tattersall’s Club and eventually bought and ran the Ship Inn on Stanley Street. He owned various investment properties in South Brisbane and it appears he also purchased the house on Tillot Street as a rental property, as he never lived there.
In 1901, Paul Petsch is renting the house from Gaffney. He is followed by Harry Valentine in 1902 and 1903 and Frank Mulhall for five years from 1904. Thomas Megann is only there for a year in 1911 and then Charles Henry Meggitt moves in. He is the longest tenant of the house, residing there with his wife, Rachael, from 1912 until his death in 1922. Rachael moves out shortly after and Mrs Florence Barton then lives there, initially with her husband, Charles Edward Barton. Mrs Barton is a bit of a mystery, as she seems to be living there on her own by 1923, but no record could be found of her husband’s death. Florence doesn’t appear in the records again until 1943, when she is living with her son at Wynnum. She remains in Wynnum until her own death in March 1954.
Mrs Sarah Tibbits (also spelt Tibbots) is recorded as living at the house from 1925 until 1933. As the property was still owned by John Gaffney during this time, Sarah was also most likely renting the house. Sarah and her husband, John, had lived in the South Brisbane and Woolloongabba area since at least 1896. They moved around often and were living on nearby Walton Street when John died in 1917. Sarah then moved in with her son, John Junior, on Annerley Road at South Brisbane. Around this time she was injured in a sulky accident, which saw her admitted to hospital with head injuries.
When Sarah moved to the house on Tillot Street in 1925, she lived with her other sons, Norman and Richard, as well as Richard’s wife, Blanche. In 1929, the owner of the Tillot Street house, John Gaffney, died and the house passed into the hands of the Public Curator of Queensland. Sarah continued to rent the property however. Sarah moved out around 1933 and Francis Whitby was the new resident. He lived there until at least 1938.
The Public Curator of Queensland held onto the property for almost twenty years, and presumedly continued to rent it out. They sold it to Tadeusz Choros in June 1950 and less than a year later, Esme Elizabeth Vincenzi purchased the property.
The House Style
The house on Tillot Street was most likely a basic “Colonial Gable” design, when built by Robert Finney. This style was common between the 1870s an 1890s in Brisbane. In its most basic form, this design has a steeply-pitched gable roof (with the ridge line running parallel to road), a verandah spanning the width of the house at the front, a floor plan that is only one room deep, and a skillion-roofed verandah at the rear. The houses would sometimes have a central living room with a bedroom either side, but more commonly had a central hallway with a living room on one side and a bedroom on the other. The front verandah usually had double hung sash windows, or French doors, opening into each room. The verandah would also usually have a separate, lower roof, which could be straight or curved. The balustrade of the front verandah was normally a simple timber design. The rear verandahs were often enclosed to house the bathroom and kitchen and varied in size and shape.
It is likely that the current configuration of the Tillot St house, with the central hallway and rooms either side, is the original layout. By 1924, the house had been extended at the rear. It is difficult to tell from the quality of the image, but it appears to retain this size and shape until 1946 when an aerial photo was taken.
The house has since been altered further, with the front verandah being partially enclosed, the rear of the house extended, the original galvanised iron roof sheeting replaced with tiles and the original double hung timber windows removed. The interior has also been modernised and reconfigured, however, it still retains many original features of a humble, Victorian-era, Queensland worker’s cottage.
This is only an extract from the full history I uncovered for this house. References citing the sources of the information contained in this report have been omitted from this online version to make it easier to read. Some images and maps have also been cropped to show details more clearly. Please contact me if you would the details of any references, or if you want to know where to find the full size versions of the images and maps.